On June 6 1896, a meeting was held in the home of Mr. George Post with over thirty people in attendance. This first worship service was led by Mr. Cobbs. Caledonia Baptist Church was formally organized on October 28, 1896; The church was recognized by the Niagara Hamilton Association of Baptist Churches on November 17, 1896. A church building was erected two years later where we worshiped for the next 92 years.
On June 19, 1988, the first worship service was held at our current location. At that time, we reminded ourselves: "The Lord has said, "Behold I will do a new thing!" Our congregation have a beautiful new building to "make all things new" but as a congregation we must first remember that we serve the Lord Jesus Christ and must remain true to him. We have a great opportunity in the growing community to share our faith with a hurt and dying world. To God be All the Glory!"